Revisited
by: Ryan • May 9, 2012 • no comments
(Importing text file) |
(Importing text file) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | For a more complete explanation and discussion of this issue, go to [ | + | For a more complete explanation and discussion of this issue, go to [[Blog:Main/Why_You_Need_to_Submit_Jury_Instructions_in_a_Bench_Trial|Submitting Jury Instructions in a Bench Trial]] . In the meantime, today's opinion in [http://www.publications.ojd.state.or.us/Publications/A145571.pdf ''State v. Massey''] is a good reminder why you should get the judge on the record adopting or rejecting jury instructions, even in a bench trial. Though there was enough evidence to survive MJOA, the judge's erroneous adoption of the ''Miles ''instruction in a bench trial resulted in the conviction being reversed. |
As I have mentioned before, special jury instructions -- if they are accurate -- that the judge declines to give or follow (whether jury or bench trial) puts the defendant in a much more defense-favorable posture on appeal than a denied MJOA. When should you ask for a special jury instruction? Every time, but especially when guilt or innocence depends on an interpretation of a particular word or phrase. See the discussion [https://libraryofdefense.org/Ambiguity_and_Jury_Instructions here.] | As I have mentioned before, special jury instructions -- if they are accurate -- that the judge declines to give or follow (whether jury or bench trial) puts the defendant in a much more defense-favorable posture on appeal than a denied MJOA. When should you ask for a special jury instruction? Every time, but especially when guilt or innocence depends on an interpretation of a particular word or phrase. See the discussion [https://libraryofdefense.org/Ambiguity_and_Jury_Instructions here.] | ||
{{wl-publish: 2012-05-09 20:22:04 -0700 | Ryan }} | {{wl-publish: 2012-05-09 20:22:04 -0700 | Ryan }} | ||
Revision as of 19:10, December 21, 2012
For a more complete explanation and discussion of this issue, go to Submitting Jury Instructions in a Bench Trial . In the meantime, today's opinion in State v. Massey is a good reminder why you should get the judge on the record adopting or rejecting jury instructions, even in a bench trial. Though there was enough evidence to survive MJOA, the judge's erroneous adoption of the Miles instruction in a bench trial resulted in the conviction being reversed.
As I have mentioned before, special jury instructions -- if they are accurate -- that the judge declines to give or follow (whether jury or bench trial) puts the defendant in a much more defense-favorable posture on appeal than a denied MJOA. When should you ask for a special jury instruction? Every time, but especially when guilt or innocence depends on an interpretation of a particular word or phrase. See the discussion here.
